Wednesday, 10 March 2010

Research for report My aims

So far my ideas to approach research have involved a questionaire, a research of better understanding of Ashford vs Jenkins, a deconstructive analysis of boths trailers. I intend to apply other theories like Alan Moore's views on adaptation and question the nature of cross media branding and transmedia.

Tuesday, 9 March 2010

The worth of the Artist - Discussion of Alan Moore

http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2009/mar/01/alan-moore-profile-watchmen

Alan Moore,
HE argued that film watered down his work in graphic Novels.

"In Moore's view, the film industry as a whole is guilty of "watering down our collective cultural imagination". He has likened the cinema-going public to freshly hatched birds with mouths open as Hollywood feeds them regurgitated worms.

"It seems to be kind of a reflex these days: if something works as a novel, then it will work even better as a film and a video game and a comic book ... I try to do things in comics that cannot be repeated by television by movies by interactive entertainment.""

Both of these quotes it is obvious that Moore felt his art restrained within boundaries of a medium that was being forced to do things that could or more seeminglyy had to be made in order to work for a movie adaptation.
Moore by going againast this and trying to make things in his medium others could not replicate shows how artists want some ownership over there work and not corperations buying them out and prostituting their creations.

"It is a view shared by Terry Gilliam, one of several directors who briefly took up the challenge of bringing the epic to the screen. "Reducing the story to a two or two-and-a-half hour film seemed to me to take away the essence of what Watchmen is about," he said."

He says how by reducing a idea your taking away from it. And for someone who worked at Dc for them to say his ideas were there's shows that the industry is now so obsessed over money that the very artists and creators of concept are being ignored. No longer are they getting famous for their hard work. No longer is the artist whos passion created it coming across but instead a desire to sell and force these watered down versions down our throats.

Yes the industry of film benifits but at the expence of the artist

My Review of Matt McAllisters theories

In this article i am reviewing a article by the above, I see this as a way to try and understand and get insight on the reasons the industry world has turned it's eye on comic book adaptations. And has tried to bridge cult and mainstream to maximise profits.

Films are becomeing all about spectacles, big budgets, big stars, big revenues generated, big explosions... Tries to appear big leaning to bigger is better philosiphy. By spending more on advertising appealing to a global market and by making focus of importance a opening weekend these companies are searching for concepts and characters that are "franchise friendly" with a tendancy to go for

"...the dominance of the action-adventure, special effects-oriented "popcom" thriller."


"one could argue that the style and format of these movies--perhaps exploiting the serialized narrative structure and visual modalities of comics indirectly influenced the episodic and cliffhanger nature of the action film genre,"

THe second quote i feel enphasises the methology carried from comic to film and vice versa. In a sense film benifits from learning new visual styles and stratagies while forcing it's own upon the comics it adapts to its format

"modern comic book-based films have helped establish the industrial formula of the Hollywood popcorn blockbuster: fantastic action movie as cultural event. Comic book materials attract a youthful movie going demographic, appeal to nostalgic older audiences, and offer thrills and well-defined archetype characters, especially heroes who also have well-established track records for popularity, licensing, and sequel potential."

With both a large fanbase and easy transferable characters this quote sums up easily why companys are so keen to include comic and make them into films and media events. THe ability to sequal these as well carrying fans on a forever consuming nature devouring a concept til it has dried out


"Ang Lee-directed Hulk (2003), "the Hulk movie was a study of anger, and people wanted a popcom movie [. . . Our Hulk will be a diet Hulk. Lighter. Focusing on the love story, Hulk as hero, and his battle with the villain" (qtd. in Hammer 112).""

Perhaps the most insulting quote exploring way films sacrifice the characters they buy, the story's and plotlines for a easy selling strategy. In doing so taking a low concept film and making it high concept so it is easier to promote It is clear in this quote there is no regret for loss of character. It has become JUST BUISNESS.
I question the morality of this. In the same article Johnson argues the way the complex and heavily depth character Wolverine in film portrayals has became much more simplistic. Losing the very things that appealed to fans.
This is in a sense a betrayal on the films parts to the base material.

I'd arge that while this article says how film has taken stylistic aproaches, see no further than SIN City it is bastardising it by taking the very reasons products like this are loved and reducing them to nothing more than one more in a never ending comercial machine.


Batman first two films with their theme made sponsorship hard with cross branded work with companies like McDonalds

"hypercommercial Hollywood seems to tolerate sex and violence more than political edginess and character complexity."

This final quote is my key point and problem, Hollywood tollerates, It is not that it cares, it is that it uses what it wants. It doesn't take a product and remakes it, it takes what it wants and puts out what it wants, leaving much out. They'll leave things they dislike out but the very fans that the concept appealed to may possibly be removed.

Peopel like things for different reasons. I like the politix and character complexity of Code Geass, yet by this quote Hollywood would remove the two main interest points of my favourite product were they to make that a film. It would remove what i like to sell it to a world that moves on with films like it devours food or sleeps. Just one more in a neverending cycle.

That is my problem with this, the fans stick with and love the concepts. THe mass audience just see it cause they want to go see another film. They don't care or stick with it. By taking the thing they like and removing best parts of it they are stopping people with most heart for its passion. They remove love of film, and love of a concept for "Bums in Seats" and this is Hollywoods most unforgivable crime.

They use formulayic natures to make it easy to sell as they are afraid, and yes they will lose money, but they forget they are selling art, since when has Art every been about facts and figures. When i left school i had a choice maths or film. Film was always a risk but it is passionate, maths is cold. And that passion comes across and most films i enjoy are ones i can tell were made with love. This stratagy hollywood suggests removes that.

Monday, 8 March 2010

High Concept

High Concept,

High concept is the third thing that transfers easily,
It is most significant in that it is a easy selling point to unknown audiences.
A high concept product is one with a plot that can be summed up in a single sentance.
It reduces the idea that keeps the main story intact even in its simplified version.

Most Hollywood films are easily reducable to this. The danger is when just the High Concept is transfered much is lost. By reducing it to a simple sentance it is like saving a photo into jpeg, the idea is compressed. Keeping some of the substance but losing something.

An example in recent films is Dragonball Evolution, the characters transfered,
But the concept that went across was that it was all big ott fights, big flashy moves and seven dragonballs. Much of the minor parts were lost. While the idea of saving the world and things mentioned above were still there, all the history and greater issues that couldn't possibly be summed up in one sentance were taken out.

The danger is always there, how can something be summed up in a single sentance and have depth. How can the depth of a product be transfered in doing this? And more, should it?

I mentioned earlier the danger of Media transference is the way audience has to back track through all previous products. And media in it's growth is now getting to stage so franchises are so big you will never be able to go through every part of them.

It was flaw of matrix that while some loved it others were confused and anoyed others not getting the "IN" references.

Wednesday, 24 February 2010

Transmedia Spectacle vs Transmedia storytelling

Aarset said at the end of his article Follow the Money. Nothing more true can be said about the nature of the media industry these days. Films, games, books and other elements of media are coming together for modern Franchise events movies.

The must have films, becoming the must have games, books and endless barage of media texts. There is so many multipe elements to a story now as they branch out in every possiblen direction in their endless attempt to make money.

The industry as a whole is now a combination of industries working together in order to produce the endless elements of these corperate intextual comodities. So much so films are now becoming tools and in a sense advertise,me

Tuesday, 23 February 2010

Reasons for what i highlighted and didn't

Specifically in my research i have tried to openly look at a range of websites by using academic scholar feature of google. And the results have been surprisingly good in quality.

The first three slides, deal with a website that actually in itself has done a comparison between the spirits within and advent children. This makes a interesting debate about Barthes' theories. And examines what is actually transfered between medias and what can not be which presents the flaw in transmedia with games.

The slides4 and 5 are from a very descriptive article that takes a more negative stand on transmedia storytelling and crossbranding. This examines perhaps the failings in both Advent Children and Spirits Within. This i feel counterbalances a perhaps strong bias of mine.

6, 7 and 8 go into detail about final fantasy role in transmedia with 9 going into plot of spirits within.

Essentially all of it gives backgroud and areas into my research. I intend to examine things further with questionaires, comparison of trailers and main scenes and further research into Jenkins vs Aarseth

Final Fantasy Spirits Within trailer

Final Fantasy Spirit's Within Trailer

I think the interesting thing in looing at the trailer for this media product is the way it refers to pre existing ideas and such without using any reference other than name Final Fantasy to previous works withing the series.

The trailer itself seems very Sci-fi in it's approach and the characters look very American. The reason i bring this up is that the characters from the games are abstract of nationality. They are implaceable and definately not American.

The Very sci-fi action genre this trailer tries to appeal to is not the fans of final fantasy who know of the sword weilding, fantasy Rpg following a extroadinary adventure but a American movie goer who sees action packed blockbusters. The removal of recognisable characters, the genre change all point out despite the same name this is not a Final Fantasy piece but a thing of same name alone.

It seems more Aliens than Final Fantasy. As the extracts I have highlighted mention this film was to go on to be a flop. Possibly due to all this change and change of audience.

The trailer tries making Final Fantasy high concept which in doing so is dangerous as most Final Fantasy plots are so deep and cover so much no single sentance can ever sum them up. The fact this one can be shows how different it is to it's predecessors.

Action film bout aliens, and a mission to save the planet. Very High Concept theme if i ever heard one.

[Coming soon Final Fantasy Advent Children trailer review and comparison]